At a press conference today, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said that Friday’s nationwide ground stop ordered by the FAA was related to work replacing outdated copper wire with a fiber optic line at a “remote FAA facility.” The secretary said that this was “routine maintenance,” rather than the result of a major modernization effort. He told reporters that it was “such an old wire that it was being discontinued, meaning that line was going to get shut down,” necessitating the upgrade.
What wasn’t clear, according to Secretary Duffy, was the root cause of the problem. He said that it could have been faulty hardware, a misconfigured router, or “incompetence” on the part of contractor L3Harris. Regardless, what followed was the newly installed router “flooding” other routers in the Air Traffic Control system. Duffy said that there were “over 1,000 connection attempts every 4 to 5 seconds,” causing disruption to radar feeds and communication with planes.
I feel that might be actually worse than the supposed AI integration mistake, that a single mistake in one place can bring almost everything down. I don’t know which is really true, but wow. What a mess.
It would be worse if it were true, but they’re lying to cover their ass about the disastrous attempt to integrate slop into a previously functional system.
ATC systems are designed with redundancies, you cannot knock them offline by snipping one cable.
If the new SMART system, of which only a single aspect was rolled out, was to blame, how was it working for 2-months in DC and FL, and for 3 days at the national level?
The only thing that system was doing was calculating optimized routes, which is a great use case for AI. Nothing in SMART is granted any sort of control. Humans must approve any suggested routes.
Which could mean that their AI was communicating hallucinated or otherwise unsafe routes
It could mean that their AI overloaded the communications systems, and they had to execute their rollback plan
All I know for certain is that the official narrative is a lie, there are many redundancies in ATC, you can’t bring the whole system down by clipping one wire. Also, the dude who made that shit up clearly doesn’t understand how a network switch works.
I feel that might be actually worse than the supposed AI integration mistake, that a single mistake in one place can bring almost everything down. I don’t know which is really true, but wow. What a mess.
It’s almost as if Elon Musk cutting those 400 engineers from the FAA might not have been a great idea.
Outlook servers with a noose around the neck: First time?
Aircraft have at least two of every important system for exactly that reason, someone forgot to tell the towers.
It’s literally listed in the project 2025 playbook though so not ATCs fault they’re being used as political pawns
The towers have backup systems too. Like a hospital, if the computers go down, they switch to physical charts and telephones.
Honestly, calling a national ground stop made this into a much bigger problem than it needed to be.
It would be worse if it were true, but they’re lying to cover their ass about the disastrous attempt to integrate slop into a previously functional system.
ATC systems are designed with redundancies, you cannot knock them offline by snipping one cable.
If the new SMART system, of which only a single aspect was rolled out, was to blame, how was it working for 2-months in DC and FL, and for 3 days at the national level?
The only thing that system was doing was calculating optimized routes, which is a great use case for AI. Nothing in SMART is granted any sort of control. Humans must approve any suggested routes.
It was a communications issue
Which could mean that their AI was communicating hallucinated or otherwise unsafe routes
It could mean that their AI overloaded the communications systems, and they had to execute their rollback plan
All I know for certain is that the official narrative is a lie, there are many redundancies in ATC, you can’t bring the whole system down by clipping one wire. Also, the dude who made that shit up clearly doesn’t understand how a network switch works.
Yeah, that sounds like they told someone who knew nothing about the tech to make something up to cover, not realizing the lie has to make sense.