After the release of Grand Theft Auto VI this week, Rockstar employees like me can make history again. We need union recognition to safeguard our jobs, says animation programmer Nestor Uriarte
That’s not terribly surprising, it’s like Hollywood, not a store, once a project is finished, there’s only so many people you need to hold down the production fort until you ramp up for something else.
But I can agree, like film work, they could still use a good union that represents them, no matter which studio they work for
Yup, sofa designers are single-use only employees. Once they’ve designed their one sofa, their usefulness to society is spent. Surely they can’t design two sofas in a single lifetime.
It doesn’t have to be this way. For all their faults, you don’t hear about this stuff from Nintendo. They somehow manage to have developers who have worked there for 40 years and outside of the “star” developers like Miyamoto, they don’t do this either. It’s a different philosophy: Short term profits vs. fostering talent long term.
That’s because when you fire a bunch of people in japan your company tanks in the market cause people think you are failing (there are a lot of worker rights so you cannot easily fire a bunch of people unless you are in the deep red).
Apparently in the US that makes the company soar cause less expenses and more profit for shareholders. That is so backwards. People that made the product suffer and people that have no idea how to make the product profit.
You don’t need 400 asset creators sitting around while you’re prototyping game mechanics for a year. And those people are probably needed elsewhere, in another studio. All that this will achieve is shifting most people to fixed term contracts or flexible contracts instead of full time employment.
Many studios run 1.5 games (one in full production, another in prototype) to help solve this but it requires near perfect scheduling to pull off and that’s super hard to achieve. Some studios go all in on one title.
The way games are bought creates this pattern - that’s why many are trying to shift to service payments, but consumers hate it.
You can have “buy once, play forever” with seasonal staff or you can have “pay monthly” with fully long-term staff - but you can’t have both.
Sofistry. The real problem is they mass hire and mass fire constantly so that they can manipulate how they appear to investors in different quarters to maximize investments.
You do not need thousand of people to work on a project unless you build the game from scratch, and those companies don’t develop their own engine anymore.
Luckily a lot of those people end up creating indie games with very small studios and that’s where I find most of the good games of today.
Nature of the beast I guess, not nothing to be done about it, but it’s not as straightforward as a job that is persistent. I’m just noting the reality of it, seems to me a sector wide union can remedy some of the issues here, I don’t see you creating another solution to it?
Instead of crunching then firing, it would make more sense to interleave releases (like another Red Dead), so departments can work on the other game instead of getting laid off, or having nothing to do.
Which is of course what some game and movie studios do.
I get they were trying to make the biggest game of all time, but that doesn’t necessarily make sense these days…
I’d be amazed if they spent more on advertising than labor.
Unless a company is going under or can prove financial hardship (eg no shareholder returns, payouts, bonuses) companies really ought to be on the hook for treble damages from lost wages when they lay people off without cause. 10x for temp workers and workers contracted through external companies, maybe 3x for internals.
Zero reason why rockstar can’t reorganize and add these folks to another project in the pipeline.
I mean, project hires are extremely common in many industries, not just movies and games. It’s completely normal to take a project position that only lasts the length of the project and leaves you without a job when it ends.
This is DOGE logic. This is the shit that erased decades of institutional knowledge and understanding from nearly every aspect of the US government. For nothing in return.
By this logic there are no permanent jobs in the US aside from those like tenured professors and Supreme Court justices.
Not a good argument man. The temp worker thing is because of the common practice of using staffing companies to not provide full benefits to workers that they deem less priority. In pharma IT is almost always external because they don’t want to pay the expensive health insurance, bonuses, PTO, yearly raises and benefits and want to fire on a whim.
Plus there’s no real way to sue a company for letting you go in these arrangements. They’ll gladly pay the staffing company more than double your compensation for this, and that staffing company will make you pay the most money you’ve ever paid for health insurance with the worst copays, deductibles and coinsurances you’ve ever seen.
Don’t be an ass and point out there’s exceptions. We all know this. There’s what’s common and business and usual, and that’s this shit.
That’s not terribly surprising, it’s like Hollywood, not a store, once a project is finished, there’s only so many people you need to hold down the production fort until you ramp up for something else.
But I can agree, like film work, they could still use a good union that represents them, no matter which studio they work for
This is a relatively recent trend. The video game industry worked just fine for decades without doing massive layoffs after every major release.
wait, so every time that furniture company produces a sofa, they have to laid off people who made that sofa?
They might lay off the designer of the sofa once it reaches the production stage because you don’t need the designer once the design is complete.
Yup, sofa designers are single-use only employees. Once they’ve designed their one sofa, their usefulness to society is spent. Surely they can’t design two sofas in a single lifetime.
DLC is a way to keep these people busy and on the payroll until tge next project ramps up.
People also hate the on DLCs
People hate DLCs if they get the impression it was comtent cut from the main game. They are usually fine with additional content made after release.
It doesn’t have to be this way. For all their faults, you don’t hear about this stuff from Nintendo. They somehow manage to have developers who have worked there for 40 years and outside of the “star” developers like Miyamoto, they don’t do this either. It’s a different philosophy: Short term profits vs. fostering talent long term.
That’s because when you fire a bunch of people in japan your company tanks in the market cause people think you are failing (there are a lot of worker rights so you cannot easily fire a bunch of people unless you are in the deep red). Apparently in the US that makes the company soar cause less expenses and more profit for shareholders. That is so backwards. People that made the product suffer and people that have no idea how to make the product profit.
Have you worked in the game industry?
You don’t need 400 asset creators sitting around while you’re prototyping game mechanics for a year. And those people are probably needed elsewhere, in another studio. All that this will achieve is shifting most people to fixed term contracts or flexible contracts instead of full time employment.
Many studios run 1.5 games (one in full production, another in prototype) to help solve this but it requires near perfect scheduling to pull off and that’s super hard to achieve. Some studios go all in on one title.
The way games are bought creates this pattern - that’s why many are trying to shift to service payments, but consumers hate it.
You can have “buy once, play forever” with seasonal staff or you can have “pay monthly” with fully long-term staff - but you can’t have both.
Sofistry. The real problem is they mass hire and mass fire constantly so that they can manipulate how they appear to investors in different quarters to maximize investments.
You do not need thousand of people to work on a project unless you build the game from scratch, and those companies don’t develop their own engine anymore.
Luckily a lot of those people end up creating indie games with very small studios and that’s where I find most of the good games of today.
If you overlap multiple game in dev then workers can switch over to another one when their current one ships.
Like other software and content companies don’t do this around big releases. They find work for their talent
How I read your comment: “You have to understand that water is coming down from the sky, so of course everyone is going to get wet”.
And nothing can be done about it, huh.
Nature of the beast I guess, not nothing to be done about it, but it’s not as straightforward as a job that is persistent. I’m just noting the reality of it, seems to me a sector wide union can remedy some of the issues here, I don’t see you creating another solution to it?
Instead of crunching then firing, it would make more sense to interleave releases (like another Red Dead), so departments can work on the other game instead of getting laid off, or having nothing to do.
Which is of course what some game and movie studios do.
I get they were trying to make the biggest game of all time, but that doesn’t necessarily make sense these days…
I’d be amazed if they spent more on advertising than labor.
Unless a company is going under or can prove financial hardship (eg no shareholder returns, payouts, bonuses) companies really ought to be on the hook for treble damages from lost wages when they lay people off without cause. 10x for temp workers and workers contracted through external companies, maybe 3x for internals.
Zero reason why rockstar can’t reorganize and add these folks to another project in the pipeline.
I mean, project hires are extremely common in many industries, not just movies and games. It’s completely normal to take a project position that only lasts the length of the project and leaves you without a job when it ends.
temp workers are temporary, because there arw very few jobs that need do be done for decades, or even years.
This is DOGE logic. This is the shit that erased decades of institutional knowledge and understanding from nearly every aspect of the US government. For nothing in return.
it proved that most of the jobs they were trying to cut were necessary, but were all the jobs needed?
By this logic there are no permanent jobs in the US aside from those like tenured professors and Supreme Court justices.
Not a good argument man. The temp worker thing is because of the common practice of using staffing companies to not provide full benefits to workers that they deem less priority. In pharma IT is almost always external because they don’t want to pay the expensive health insurance, bonuses, PTO, yearly raises and benefits and want to fire on a whim.
Plus there’s no real way to sue a company for letting you go in these arrangements. They’ll gladly pay the staffing company more than double your compensation for this, and that staffing company will make you pay the most money you’ve ever paid for health insurance with the worst copays, deductibles and coinsurances you’ve ever seen.
Don’t be an ass and point out there’s exceptions. We all know this. There’s what’s common and business and usual, and that’s this shit.