I was about 13 so we played after school and before we had to go home for tea, it was super creepy though and I still feel uneasy in the fog.

I played Silent hill with my friend, whenever one of us got scared we threw the controller to the other one, there were times that we were playing 10 seconds each.

Its old but I think fits, the original silent hill I needed a pad and paper at all times. Some puzzles were quite tricky.