The proper protocol when wanting to phase out a particular file format is to provide an import codec, so it can at least be imported. And then don’t include an export codec.
That this is a controversy shows us that Microsoft isn’t even trying anymore. It’s just making enshitified software on the premise that people and businesses will automatically buy it.
Maybe it’s time to switch to LibreOffice.
My thesis in LaTeX from 2003 still looking fine today. 😃
way to reinforce the old versions are the best versions. now more people won’t upgrade to your bullshit subscription, and maybe you’ll even see a few cancellations of those as users migrate back to their old perpetual licensed versions. the one certainty is deprecating and removing backwards compatibility features will not gain you even a single new subscriber.
MS has been screwing over third parties since 2013 at the earliest I could find with regards to sabotaging
.docx/.pptx/.xlsxon LibreOffice, so it’s no surprise that they’d mess up compatibility with older documents on their own suites as well in order to keep the subscription money rolling in.Last time I thought legacy
.doc/.ppt/.xlsdocuments still worked fine in LibreOffice, plus there’s just using ODF equivalents instead.I’m just glad they’re not trying to sabotage WINE/Proton and DXVK/VKD3D in a similar way to how they’ve been sabotaging LibreOffice for years yet.
The original phrase was “DOS ain’t done til Lotus won’t run.” I heard this in the 90s. It was SOP well before the new format whose only two purposes seemed to be to shoehorn XML into Office documents and to create a new default standard for third parties to try to meet feature parity on.
This doesn’t sound like it affects third parties, though? It affects users of newer versions of Microsoft’s own applications and means they might not correctly render documents saved by versions of word older than 2013.
If anything this probably only helps third parties at they’ll likely still respect the compatibility settings.
A company I’d worked with was stuck on Office 2003, because 2007 couldn’t load their documents correctly…
That’s when I stopped taking the “we have to use MS Office for compatibility” seriously
Yep, Libreoffice has better back compat than Office. Same with Apple Works documents. Last I checked it is the only way you can still use them on a modern Mac.
Word needs literally no changes to randomly break formatting, even when opening a document on the computer that created it.
I fucking despise Word.
Move picture to the left 1 pixel BOOM! Picasso document!
Yeah, that’s been a feature of Word since as long as i can remember, Word 6 (for Windows) or something. It’s clearly one that they cherish over at MS as despite countless other changes, they cling on to that feature as if their corporate contracts depend on it.
How bad would it really be if everyone just started using LibreOffice? You don’t have to pay for Microsoft Office.
The office suite is only half the issue. The pseudo-standard OOXML (.docx & co.) is intentionally broken. Open Document Format is the standard you want to save your documents and tables with. Can even use it in all kinds of office suites (hence the standard part).
Bad. Lots of business processes are built on Office specifically. Excel macros, VBscript, Access databases and applications…
Lots of business processes are built on Office specifically.
shrug And lots of business processes aren’t.
If you’re a big enough business to have an Excel spreadsheet-of-doom or two, you should really start looking at alternatives. This is a heads-up from Microsoft that they’re going to start breaking whatever they consider “legacy software” real soon now. I mean, more than the usual amount of breakage.
It’s all fun and games until one day you get an update and your favorite spreadsheet-of-doom opens up with a dialog box saying “Oopsie! This is a legacy file format. Functionality will be degraded.” and nothing works anymore.
Oh. I figured everything was compatible. I’ve never messed with anything that complex. Access scares me.
Even if it was fully compatible, they’re stuck there forever by iron-clad contracts and the sunk cost fallacy. There is no escaping how deep Microsoft’s got their hooks into most large organizations, which, sadly, control the vast majority of the economy and employ the majority of people. It doesn’t matter that LibreOffice works better and is free, if SuperHyperGlobalMegaCorp Inc. already has a 500-year multi-bajillion-dollar contract with Microsoft that requires the use of Windows, Office 365, Sharepoint, Teams, Outlook, Copilot, MSSQL, Github and all Microsoft’s other corporate shovelware, none of which works properly unless it’s connected to all the other pieces and finds ways to punish you if you aren’t using them with each other.
There’s also lock-in from user experience. If most office workers have, say, 20 years of Microsoft Office experience, what’s the cost of retraining and productivity loss from transitioning them?
People don’t like having even slight changes to their workflow imposed, because it causes unpredictable disruptions when they’re trying to complete some task down the line and suddenly they realize that they don’t know how to do something that they used to be able to do.
Once you’ve got a lot of inertia behind a proprietary system, hard to get people moved off it.
There’s a reason that a lot of proprietary software vendors give student discounts, to get that initial experience-based lock-in in place.
I was surprised recently when I tried to do some spreadsheet work in LibreOffice, copy and paste was fundamentally broken in a way that it took twice as long since I had to do it twice.
It wasn’t even that complicated of a task, just opening up a CSV, merging some data and then adding a couple columns of data.
I ended up giving up and begrudgingly using Google sheets. It sucked too (why they don’t have a keyboard shortcut to add rows and columns baffles me) but at least it works.
i’ve had to give up on libreoffice on a few occasions as well, when it didn’t behave as expected or simply couldn’t do something that an old office program could.
This really is the problem. The world runs on Excel, and it’s the one thing no one has ever created a viable alternative to.
Yup, excell still dominates the space. For an average joe, libre office does “eveything” excell can…but oh no. There’s so many layers to excell it’s going to take many years for anyone else to catchup, not to mention whatever new shit excell cooks up in the meantime
The good news is, just about everything new in Excel is shit. I was not happy with the Copilot button I couldn’t get rid of. The last thing I need in my super-calculator is a number guessing machine.
I use Office at work because I have to. I can’t install anything.
At home I have Macs. I use iWork because it’s included, but they stopped getting updates in favour of ones that have AI subscriptions built in. And they’re huge. I use them a bit because they’re also on my iPhone. If LibreOffice was on iOS I’d fully switch to it. Office suites on mobile seem so sketchy, except Microsoft and iWork. I never really liked iWork though, with all the controls on the right. LibreOffice is good on Mac, I just wish it were on mobile.
They’re normalizing breaking compatibility with older versions of their office suite to push subscriptions onto enterprise users.
Are they just trying to get everyone to stop using it ? Seeing how bad they can make it before that happens?
I’m ready
I already have enough trouble at work with formatting between word’s desktop app and the browser version. Not looking forward to even more headaches…
They now need software changes to fuck up the layout? I’ve seen word managing that out of the box many times in the past.
So could switching to Libre Office. Just saying.
But then you lose Excel. That’s not an option for business users.
No worries bruv, I’ll let my septugenarian boss who barely understands why we need computers know about the change.
Nah that usually only breaks new documents
How is this news? This happens every time a new version of Word comes out.
It’s literally in the click-through agreement that they don’t guarantee backwards compatibility with older releases.
good.












